It has been rumored that the Tigers may be inquiring into the asking price on Philadelphia Phillies ace Cole Hamels.
Hamels is currently 10-4 with a 3.08 ERA and 111 K’s in as many innings for the fightin’ Phils. He is a bona fide ace and would bring a dominant left-handed starter to the Tigers for the first time since, well, since when? Mickey Lolich? That may not be as far off as you think.
The Tigers would then boast a rotation of Justin Verlander, Hamels, Max Scherzer, Doug Fister, and Rick Porcello. Not bad. But at what price?
Trade this guy? You can’t be serious.
The Phillies are going to want a truckload of prospects and at least 2 highly touted ones at that. In Tiger Town we all know what that means: wonder boy Nick Castellanos.
Hamels is on the last year of his deal and will get a mega-contract on the free agent market this winter. That mega-deal would be one the Tigers simply cannot hand out as they are already paying 3 players over $20M/season.
Is a 3-month rent-a-arm worth unloading a feeble minor league system’s few valuable chips?
Castellanos is a rare find in the Tigers’ organization: an offensive player who is ear-marked as a can’t-miss guy and is now actually backing it up with his play on the field. This doesn’t come around these parts too often. He was the Tigers’ 2011 minor league hitter of the year and will be again in 2012.
At age 20, he has already tasted 3 levels of the minor leagues and has most recently been smashing AA pitching in the Eastern League, a noted pitcher’s league.
The argument for such a trade would be that Castellanos has nowhere to play in Detroit, what with Miguel Cabrera at 3rd base and all. Temporary problems don’t require permanent mistakes be risked. Victor Martinez’s contract expires after 2013, freeing up the DH slot in 2014. That’s the same year as Castellanos’ due date to the Majors. Prince Fielder can then shift to DH, Cabrera back to 1st, and the hot shot rookie at 3rd. Done. Why all the confusion?
Another question to be asked by Tigers faithful is this: would adding Hamels cure what ails the Tigers and guarantee a postseason berth and run?
He certainly wouldn’t hurt. Replacing the scuffling Drew Smyly with Hamels is an immeasurable upgrade that would surely net the Tigers some more wins in the season’s 2nd half. But what really ails the Tigers is the fact that from 5 through 9 in the batting order it’s a complete guessing game as to who might produce on any given night.
Last time I checked Cole Hamels doesn’t project as a DH on his off days. If Brennan Boesch, Jhonny Peralta, Alex Avila, and the lame duck DH Delmon Young could start hitting with authority a trade of this magnitude wouldn’t need to be considered.
But for now it is.
Remember Miguel Cabrera as a 20-year old minor leaguer (same as Castellanos) in the Florida Marlins system? At age 20 the hot shot 3rd baseman (sound familiar) hit .365 with 10 homers and 59 RBI’s in about half a season before getting the call and helping the Marlins to a World Series title.
Had the Marlins wanted to add a stud veteran lefty via trade in 2003 it would have been somebody like Mark Mulder. Mulder was 15-9 with a 3.13 ERA for the A’s that year, or very similar to the level of production Cole Hamels offers. But who would trade Miguel Cabrera?
So far in Castellanos’ age 20 season he has hit .373 with 6 homers and 44 RBI’s. Awfully Cabrera-like doesn’t it seem? Would you trade that for Mark Mulder? Cole Hamels?
Me neither. Tread lightly Dave Dombrowski. Your reputation sways in the balance.
Related Articles
Cranking up the Detroit Tigers trade rumors
2012 MLB trade deadline rumors and candidates
About Joe White
Altuve would look good at 2B
Stick with the rookie 3rd baseman and get Fister going.
Thanks for the comments. Spot on David. Couldn’t agree more with what you said. And if we couldn’t like Delmon any less, than mustache really sold it!
Joe, I think your spot on here. Trading Nick would be foolish if we were only getting Cole as a rental. The ONLY reason you would make this trade is if you could sign Cole before finishing the trade, but then again, like you said, the asking price will be too much, considering the bloated payroll we have right now. For fun, lets just imagine that we could sign Cole to a decent deal. I think said signing would become somewhat of a domino effect. How about Jed Lowrie? Having Cole, would you then consider giving up a Rick Porcello or a Max Sherzer? How about giving up Jacob Turner? Just fun to think about. One thing I think the Tigers HAVE to do before the trade deadline is find a replacement for DELMON YOUNG! This guy is HORRIBLE. I don’t think there’s an english word that fully describe how HORRIFIC he is! He CANNOT play the game of baseball. Nope. Not at all.
Denny McClain was a Right Hand Pitcher.
Fixed that. Thanks. Meant Lolich. Wasn’t born yet back then so I’ll use that as my excuse!
Dominant left-handed starter since Denny McClain…Denny was right-handed.
I’m with you, Joe…to high a price to pay for a three month rental.
Can’t be decimating the farm for a rental that we can’t afford long term. I’d love having Hamels, but that cost is just too high. I’d rather go for Altuve or just offer everything for Castro. We’d lose the farm, but we’d have great young talent under control for a whole. Bring in a back of the rotation SP and hope the underperformers wake up.
I’d rather see a trade for Altuve.
I’ll be very disappointed if they trade Castellanos. It’s not worth a rental player. See Doyle Alexander for John Smoltz