Detroit Tigers rumors: and Porcello goes to…

In 6 days, the Detroit Tigers’ Rick Porcello will turn 24 years old. He already has 4 full season of MLB service under his belt. He plays for a team suddenly with one too many starters and an infield defense that doesn’t suit his skill set as a pitcher. Add it all up and Porcello is being shopped hard by the Tigers and might have a new home by the time the ball drops in New York City.

Despite a career ERA of 4.55 and WHIP of 1.42, Porcello is an extremely attractive trade target for teams looking to fill a hole in their rotation. It’s not every day that you find a pitcher who is as young as Porcello with a resume full of big game experience as he has. Porcello is also under team control through 2015, which adds even more to his allure.

Rick Porcello, Detroit Tigers

Rick Porcello

With Anibal Sanchez re-joining the Tigers last week via a 5-year free agent deal, Detroit had to consider their 2013 rotation members. Locked in stone are Sanchez, Justin Verlander, Doug Fister, and Max Scherzer. That leaves one spot to be doled out between Porcello and Drew Smyly.

The Tigers, quite simply, prefer Smyly. The 23-year old lefty had a strong rookie season. He pitched in 23 games, 18 of those being starts, and went 4-3 with a 3.99 ERA and 1.27 WHIP. Most impressive were the 94 K’s in 99.1 innings pitched.

The Tigers’ front office favors strikeout pitchers and Porcello just doesn’t have the knack. Consider that the Big 4 in Detroit’s rotation punched out 774 hitters in 2012 covering just 783.1 innings of work. Porcello struck out a mere 107 in 176.1 innings.

Smyly is not only a lefty that the rotation could desperately use, but fits neatly into the strikeout/inning type of pitcher the Tigers covet.

What is interesting is that the Tigers usually proceed very quietly when it comes to their operations in the trade and free agent market. However, no secret is being made of the fact that Porcello is on the block.

Three teams have already stepped up to the buffet: Seattle, Baltimore, and San Diego.

Seattle is a very common trading partner with Dave Dombrowski and has also inquired into Brennan Boesch’s availability, so I would give them the edge in working out a deal.

Detroit wants another strong bullpen arm as well as a right-handed hitting outfielder. Some recent trades involving other teams seem to indicate that the Tigers can name a fairly stout price for Porcello. Seattle themselves just traded 29-year old lefty starter Jason Vargas to the Angels for Kendrys Morales’ impact bat.

If a fairly average 29-year old can net Morales then Detroit should absolutely expect a difference maker in the bullpen and a complimentary bat for the outfield.

Some players from the 3 teams mentioned that fit the bill include:

Outfield: Casper Wells (Seattle), Chris Denorfia (San Diego), Jesus Guzman (San Diego), Nolan Reimold (Baltimore)

Reliever: Pedro Strop (Baltimore), Miguel Gonzalez (Baltimore), Brad Brach (San Diego), Brad Boxberger (San Diego), Stephen Pryor (Seattle)

The trap in trading Porcello is that it really thins out the ‘next in line’ department. To think that Detroit’s starting 5 will all make 30+ starts is simply naïve. There is almost zero depth left in the Tigers’ system as guys like Jacob Turner, Andy Oliver, and Adam Wilk are no longer around.

That’s what makes a starter/reliever combo guy like Miguel Gonzalez an attractive option.

Don’t be surprised to see Boesch moved in whatever deal Porcello leaves in. All that’s left now are the details.

To receive an email each time a new Tigers article is published, fill out the Email Notification Form

[Follow me on Twitter @isportsJoe]

  • itsfun

    I hope Porcello stays in Detroit. Sooner or later someone will get injured and they will need another starting pitcher. The lineup is plenty good enough to win the American League again.

  • lungger82

    absolutley darwin barney is all i will trade for porcello throw another guy in there with boesch if you want but i think porcello is solid number five and great out of the bull pen in the playoffs if we need him i don’t think trading him just yet is a good idea…I think letting him pitch the five spot and deal him mid season might be a better idea…

  • Dale

    Darwin Barney and Carlos Marmol for Rick Porcello and Bosch

  • BobWhite

    Did not care for Sanchez deal, do not think he is worth that kind of money, I would have kept Porcello and let Sanchez go. To me they are of equal caliber.

  • Keith Richards

    Tulo or Stanton for Castellanos, Garcia, Porcello, and depending on the trade, Dirks or Peralta.

    Get it done. The future is now.

  • Joe White

    Interesting. With S. Drew off the market there is definitely a possibility that Porcello helps net a shortstop. Wouldn’t that be ironic? The ground ball pitcher is traded away to shore up the ground ball ‘D’…

  • Matt

    I think the best deal would be with Seattle – move Porcello and Boesch for Wells (Right handed LF and power bat off the bench), Charlie Furbush (LHP for long relief and spot starts) and have them throw in Carlos Triunfel – a 25 year old SS who has a range factor of 4.32, FLD% of .940 and a career .274 hitter in the Minors – all upgrades from Peralta but a guy who can get a full season at Toledo…hits all 3 of our major needs, IMO

    • Matt

      Well, the Fielding % is lower than JP’s but have to take into account the added balls he gets to