Are the Detroit Tigers their own worst enemy?

Ten weeks into the season and Detroit Tigers fans are getting that familiar feeling that some things just never change. 22 games ago the Tigers had just swept Boston in Fenway and were holding onto a lofty seven game lead in the AL Central.

Since then the Tigers have won six games and lost 16 while being outscored during that stretch by 53 runs. Even with their successes gained in recent years, it hasn’t come easy and despite a red-hot streak that seems like ages ago already, it looks like more of the same in Motown.

A quick check of the AL Central standings reveals that the Tigers still hold a 2-game division lead over the surging Royals. However, another glance reveals that the Tigers have only won two more games than the last place, and vastly improved, Twins, who only lag behind the Tigers by 3.5 games in the standings.

Jim Leyland haters were put at ease in the offseason by the hiring of the younger and more relatable Brad Ausmus. Early returns on the new manager have been favorable, but is he really that different from Leyland as a manager? The discrepancies are far from obvious. More of the same.

Justin Verlander

Justin Verlander

Ian Kinsler and Rajai Davis were brought in to ignite the Tigers on the base paths and in the clubhouse with their contagious attitudes and fiery style of play. They’ve both performed admirably but anybody hoping for a less business-like approach by the team this year has to be sorely disappointed here in mid-June. Cinch up those ties boys, Detroit Tigers Incorporated is seemingly here to stay.

With a division as shockingly tight as the AL Central, who then, is the Tigers’ biggest threat?

Chicago’s offense has been revitalized with the addition of Cuban star Jose Abreu. Their pitching, even when being led by Chris Sale, has been bad though and will ultimately be their downfall.

Kansas City is oozing with talent and if their bats could ever match their potential then they seem like the most likely candidates to chase down the Tigers once the pennant push kicks into high gear.

But even Minnesota has turned a corner and Cleveland is showing signs of life again. Unfortunately for these squads, like Chicago, pitching will probably undo both of their playoff chances, but hey, stranger things have happened.

One thing is clear, Detroit possesses more top to bottom talent than any team in the division and it’s not particularly close. Who then poses the greatest threat to unseating the Tigers? That’s the easiest question of all – it’s the Tigers themselves.

How can a team with Max Scherzer, Justin Verlander, Anibal Sanchez, Victor Martinez, Miguel Cabrera, Torii Hunter, and Ian Kinsler have a +2 run differential this deep into the season in an obviously weak division?

The reasons that can be pointed to (bad outfield defense, roller-coaster bullpen, Verlander’s struggles, lack of batting order depth) are all legitimate, but none of them acceptable.

Tigers fans, some of the best in the game, want to see some fire from the players, consistent energy, conviction, whatever it takes to show the faithful that they want it as badly as fans think they should. Tigers supporters wear it on their sleeves and they’d like to see the team join forces.

But those expecting or hoping for change aren’t likely to see it. The Tigers are who they are, even with the new faces who were expected to change the landscape. Their fight is a 162-game battle, not a game-by-game crisis. They’ve been around the block long enough to know that the law of averages will play out and that the cream almost always rises to the top. Or at least it has lately.

They’re comfortable with that, as uncomfortable as it is to watch. But press cruise control enough times, start getting heavy-eyed as the traffic comes nearer, and your chances of getting passed by a hungry young driver increases by the mile.

Tread lightly, Tigers, because eventually ‘more of the same’ has a funny way of backfiring. Actually, scratch that, don’t tread lightly, get angry and stake your claim to what is rightfully yours.

Assuming it still is.

To receive an email each time a new Tigers article is published, fill out the Email Notification Form

[Follow me on Twitter @isportsJoe]

Check out our Detroit Tigers team page for more news, rumor, and opinion and follow us on Twitter

  • TetotalingTigerFan

    Very few teams are beating the Tigers. The Tigers are losing the games. So fans of the other teams who are gloating–you aren’t beating the Tigers–the Tigers are giving you a gift–wrapped up in a beautiful package.

  • burrwick

    Good read, thanks Joe.

  • jeff s

    With our offensive woes,I think our pitchers start out with a mindset that they will need to throw a shutout every time out. That would cause most pitchers to ‘tighten up” out there; one mistake and there goes the game.
    It would be much less frustrating if The Tigers weren’t so talented. It’s not as much about losing-which is painful to watch- as it is about under-achieving.

    • Joe White

      Well said Jeff.

  • jeff s

    It appears the Tigers think they are better than the rest of the division and can win just by showing up.
    That Suarez kid looks really good. I know it’s been a small sample period and mediocrity compared to what we had would look great. Small things- he executed a sacrifice bunt, is working pitchers for walks, and an occasional clutch RBI now and then (2 homers, also) it’s a bright spot in an otherwise dismal stretch. I hope whatever the rest of the team has isn’t contagious.

  • Fran in Ar.

    I think that when certain players receive BIG contracts they just settle back and think ” I’m here and settled in”, let the other players do the work. Pay should be on performance at the end of the season. Just my thoughts.

  • Bob Clarke

    I want to watch Doug Fister,fare these guys paid too much and no incentive to achieve,

  • Vince in MN

    What happened to the aggressive base running, squeeze plays, hit and runs? Instead we’re getting the 3-run homer mentality without enough homer guys (Cabrera, V-Mart and ?). And although almost the entire pitching staff has been a disaster lately, nobody in their right mind leaves their No. 5 starter (Verlander) in for 120 pitches and 5, 6 or 7 runs game after game after game. There’s not much a manager can do to ameliorate sub-par defense of course, so you can’t rag too much on Ausmus for that. But the bottom line is the team is a mess and he is proving to be more of a contributor than a corrective force.

  • Al

    Come on Tiger’s, get it going!!!!

  • Ken

    I think I saw J.D. Martinez make four (4), count ’em, four, errors in one game recently. Major league pitchers usually start giving up runs when they see that. They don’t mean to, but obvious repeated errors cost big time.